Cryptocurrency thefts represent the largest value heists in the financial world, exemplified by the February 2025 Bybit hack where digital assets worth $1.5 billion were stolen, far surpassing the largest bank robbery of $282 million recorded in the Guinness Book of World Records. When stolen cryptocurrencies are recovered, owners face various tax consequences that largely depend on whether they originally claimed a tax deduction for the theft, what type of assets they receive back, and what value changes have occurred in the interim. It's important to note that under the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), between 2018 and 2025, personal theft losses are only deductible if they relate to a federally declared disaster, meaning most cryptocurrency theft victims cannot claim tax deductions during this period.
Recovery rates for stolen cryptocurrency vary significantly on a case-by-case basis, but the industry average is approximately 70%, offering hope to victims. If no tax deduction was originally claimed for the theft, recovered cryptocurrencies are treated as if the owner never lost them—meaning no disposal needs to be reported at the time of theft, and tax consequences only arise when the recovered assets are eventually sold or exchanged. However, if the victim previously wrote off losses from the theft—for instance, before 2018—then the recovered amount may be taxable to the extent that the deduction reduced the tax owed.
Tax implications can be particularly significant for early cryptocurrency investors who purchased at low prices and experienced substantial appreciation. For example, if an investor bought 5 Bitcoins in 2020 for $10,000 each (total value $50,000), and these were stolen in 2022 when a Bitcoin was worth $40,000 (total value $200,000), they could only have deducted the original purchase price of $50,000 as a loss. If these Bitcoins are later recovered when their value is much higher, no tax is due at the time of recovery, but when eventually sold, the gain will be calculated against the original $50,000 basis. Taxpayers should consult with experts to determine exact obligations, especially since regulations may change in 2025, potentially making certain deductions available again.
Sources:
1.
Miles Brooks
2.
3.
